(This is a SPOILER review for “The Rise of Skywalker”)
I’m not a huge fan of Star Wars. I’ve watched all the movies and some episodes of the TV shows, but, in general, I don´t love Star Wars as much as other people do. I do like the Jedi and the Force as concepts, and I’ve always enjoyed a good lightsaber battle, but I do not have a huge bond with the main characters of the original trilogy or this new one, so for me, the ending of the Skywalker saga wasn´t going to be the greatest event of 2019.
I was actually curious about how they would end the trilogy, especially after watching “The Last Jedi”, a film that divided the whole fandom and became of the most discussed movies of 2017. I didn´t like it as much as other people did, but I didn´t hate it either. I understood some of the criticism the story received, and I agreed with some of them, which led me to believe that both Disney and Kathleen Kennedy needed to do some “damage control”, in order to reunite and “heal” the fandom. And yes, Disney did some damage control.
At first, with the return of J. J. Abrams to the director chair, I thought that he could be able to fix some of the problems “The Last Jedi” had, without undercutting Rian Johnson’s vision and script. But after watching this movie, “The Rise of Skywalker”, there’s only one thing I can say: he did NOT fix the problems and he definitively undercut Johnson’s story.
The good elements of “The Rise of Skywalker”
I am a huge fan of Abrams. I love what he did with “Star Trek” and “Super 8” is one of my favorite movies of all times. However, he is not a very creative person. This movie possesses the great elements every J. J. Abrams film has: it’s entertaining, it has some great action scenes and sequences, and the comedic element works most of the time.
Even when the action sequences were longer than they should have been, I found myself enjoying all of them. They are really well directed, the choreography is great, and you can see everything that’s happening during the scene.
The cast is also good, even if their characters are very bland in general. Both Daisy Ridley and Adam Drive do a good job portraying their characters, but they have no chemistry whatsoever, so Reylo doesn’t work.
The comedy really worked in this film too. I thought Rian Johnson couldn´t handle comedy in “The Last Jedi”, which was one of the reasons that led me to criticize the movie, but Abrams knows how to do it. C3PO was, by far, the funniest character in the movie. He had the most memorable lines and his sarcasm worked really well with the other characters. There were some jokes that didn´t work, but the movie moved so fast that you just forgot about them by the end of the scene.
And yes, in terms of script, there are some good elements that the story could have explored but fails to do so spectacularly. And that is probably one of the greatest mistakes of this movie.
The trilogy that never was
“Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker” is not the kind of movie it was supposed to be. This final adventure was going to be the end of a saga that began in 1977, the “Endgame” for the “Star Wars” franchise. However, it is not. And the main problem is not that this movie doesn´t provide a satisfying ending (which it doesn´t), but that Disney never knew what this new trilogy was going to be from the very beginning.
They never planned the story. Kathleen Kennedy gave Abrams the freedom to do whatever he wanted to do with Episode VII but never asked for a coherent outline of what the new trilogy was going to be about. For that reason, when Rian Johnson was hired to handle Episode VIII, he did whatever he wanted. As Abram did before.
I’m sure that nobody knew what was going to happen, IN GENERAL, during the course of this trilogy. That was definitively the greatest mistake Disney made with Star Wars. If you take a look back at this new trilogy as a whole, you can tell that the story went back and forth. They presented some questions, they answered them and then they changed those answers again, destroying and undercutting one of the movies of the trilogy.
Now, the problem is not that these movies had different directors. The MCU has a lot of different directors handling the different films and characters, but when “Endgame” came out, everything fit perfectly. There was a coherent story that had been built since 2008.
Kathleen Kennedy was supposed to be overlooking these new movies, and I think she should have been there “forcing” Abrams to create, at least, a draft for what he wanted to do with the whole trilogy. And I’m sure she didn´t because otherwise, we would be having a different conversation about Star Wars.
Now we know that Disney decided to ignore George Lucas’s ideas for the new movies, and they were in their right to do so. However, if there’s something that no one can ever say about Lucas’s trilogies, it is that they had a story to tell, and from the very first movie to the last one, the story was clear and had a direction, even if the some of them weren´t as good as the others. I cannot say the same thing about this sequel trilogy. In fact, I would say that they created the story as they created and crafted the movies, which then led us to this situation. Outlines are the key to success, and that’s something Kevin Feige and the MCU have demonstrated over and over again.
The problem with damage control
One of the most annoying things about “The Rise of Skywalker” is that you can tell that many of the creative decisions were made not because they fit in the story, but because they wanted to please the fans that didn´t like “The Last Jedi” AND also course-correct the new trilogy.
I want to start with the most despicable and mean decision they made: Rose Tico (Kelly Marie Tran) is NOT one of the main characters. In fact, she is barely in this movie. Now, I didn´t like Kelly’s character in “The Last Jedi” because I felt the movie introduced a lot of new characters without giving them time to develop any kind of personality. However, Kelly Marie Tran was bullied for a long time, because of her character. A lot of “fans” of the franchise said terrible things about her, her looks and her acting ability. What does Lucasfilm and J. J . Abrams decide to do? Hide her in the background. The worst thing about this situation is the fact that the cast and Abrams himself DEFENDED her, and said they were very happy to have her. However, that’s definitively not what they really meant. Otherwise, Rose Tico would have had a role in this movie, instead of being a secondary character with 5 lines of dialogue. And even though some people didn´t like Rose Tico, that’s not an excuse to get rid of her. Both Abrams and Chris Terrio, who co-wrote the script, should have kept the character and, maybe, get her better lines and better scenes in this new movie. Or maybe just a proper character arc.
The Emperor is in this movie as pure fan-service. They never explain why or how he’s alive, how he built the ships he gives to Kylo Ren or anything related to him. His presence is a response to those who criticized “The Last Jedi” for killing off Snoke. It’s like “Oh, yes, Snoke was bad, but it was Palpatine who controlled him. He was the real villain all along”. That character didn’t work at all, and it was just there so we could see a cool action scene at the end of the movie featuring Sith Force lightning.
Abrams and Terrio also changed Rey’s origins AGAIN, making her the granddaughter of Palpatine. This was an idea I really liked, but somehow, they destroyed it too. I loved that they were saying: “hey, even if you are part of an evil family and your grandfather is the incarnation of the Dark Side, there’s still hope for you. You can be good. You can save the galaxy”. What did they do with this idea? They threw it away like it was nothing. At the end of this movie, Rey decides to call herself Rey Skywalker, an act that totally erases the important message they tried to include in the story. She should have embraced the Palpatine name, proving to everyone that she was more than a name, more than her blood. As I said, there were some good ideas that they decided to not explore at all.
The other little problems
I really think that this is the weakest film in this trilogy. You can enjoy the movie, and I’m sure a lot of people will. But when you stop to think about the story and the script in general, you realize how flawed it is.
The Knights of Ren are back, but they do absolutely nothing. The new characters suffer from the same problem that most of the new characters for this trilogy have suffered: they don’t have any kind of development. And the final act has a lot of similarities with “Endgame”, which really bothered me because it’s Disney who has made both films, so they should have been able to fix this PRIOR to the release of this movie.
There are also a lot of missed opportunities with characters that could have appeared in the film via cameo and others that could have had more to do in general (Dark Rey who?). However, these are the kind of problems that one could ignore because they don’t hurt the film as much as the other aspects that I pointed out.
The End
If someone had said to me, 4 years ago, that the Star Wars franchise would end up like this, I would have not believed it. The fandom is divided, the story they loved concludes poorly and the future of the franchise is not very clear (at least, in the movie area).
I do think that if you really like Star Wars, you can enjoy this film. There are enough good elements to do so, and I’m sure that if you have invested a lot of time with the characters and the universe, you will feel great after watching the movie. But as the chapter that was supposed to close one of the most important franchises of all time, I have to say: I expected more.